• Newsletters
  • Webinars
  • Podcast
  • Reports
  • About
    • Advertising
    • Contact us
    • Team
    • Contributors
  • News
  • Frontline
    • Prevention
    • Resilience
    • Response
    • Recovery
    • Learning
  • Leadership
    • Strategy
    • Government
    • Culture
    • Communication
  • People and skills
    • People moves
    • Training
    • Apprenticeships
    • Diversity and inclusion
    • Mental health and wellbeing
    • Life stages
  • Products
    • PPE
    • Vehicles
    • Medical
    • Training
    • Operational
    • Technology
  • Sustainability
    • Infrastructure
    • Transport
    • Built environment
    • Net zero
    • Climate change
  • Technology
    • Command and control
    • Data
    • Hardware
    • Software and apps
    • Digital transformation
    • Mapping and navigation
X (Twitter) LinkedIn Instagram
  • Newsletters
  • Webinars
  • Podcast
  • Reports
  • About
    • Advertising
    • Contact us
    • Team
    • Contributors
LinkedIn Instagram
Emergency Services Times
  • News
  • Frontline
  • Leadership
  • People and skills
  • Products
  • Sustainability
  • Technology
Emergency Services Times
Home > Leadership > ‘Bullying culture’ in Welsh fire services, say damning new reports
Leadership 5 February 2025

‘Bullying culture’ in Welsh fire services, say damning new reports

Catherine Levin5 February 2025Updated:6 February 2025No Comments5 Mins Read
Mid and West Wales FRS firefighters standing in a row
Mid and West Wales Firefighters. Photo credit: Martin Ellard.

Following on from the independent review in South Wales last year which described the fire service as “toxic,” two new reports into the culture of Mid and West Wales Fire and Rescue Service (MAWWFRS) and North Wales Fire and Rescue Service have found that bullying and harassment are widespread.

The chiefs of both services agreed to independent reviews by Crest Advisory into the culture of their services and the results make for difficult reading with both services found to have extensive issues with bullying and harassment and struggling to reform their cultures.

Echoing the findings of the Fenella Morris review of culture in in South Wales, the review says that “an operational boys’ club” operates in MAWWFRS serving to create division and lack of trust between senior staff and those in more junior and often non-uniformed positions. There is an emphasis on operational firefighting and it is “hindering attempts at positive cultural change.” The review is scathing about the leadership saying that staff do not have confidence in reporting poor behaviours, fearing being ostracised and retaliation.

It recommends that the leadership “embody the principles of openness, accountability, and
humility as they steer the organisation towards a more inclusive and supportive culture.”

“MAWWFRS must undergo transformative reforms, modernising its culture and structure to align with contemporary public safety priorities, addressing systemic issues, and rebuilding trust through decisive, bold and inclusive action.”

In North Wales the review finds that the leadership recognises the need to change but negative behaviours of a minority of senior staff “hindered positive cultural change.” A lack of transparency in the process is fuelling mistrust among staff, it says, and the hierarchical command and control approach does reflect the changing public safety role of fire and rescue services.

This report comes just days after the NWFRS Deputy Chief Fire Officer was suspended pending investigation into a historical social media post.

The review recommends that the “Chief Fire Officer should issue a formal, public apology that addresses past wrongdoings, acknowledges their impact on staff, and outlines the commitment to repair and improve.”

“NWFRS must embrace greater transparency, confront challenges with courage, and celebrate successes to rebuild trust and sustain meaningful cultural transformation, ensuring continued momentum under its leadership.”

Both services come under fire for the way that women are treated, with misogyny and sexism appearing to be normalised in MAWWFRS, says the report, “often dismissed as ‘banter’ but frequently crossing professional boundaries and escalating into increasingly harmful comments, creating hostile environments for women.”

Women make up 15% of the operational workforce in NWFRS with MAWWFRS behind this with 9%. In NWFRS the efforts to increase the number of women in operational roles led to the situation where “they faced external scepticism and internal doubts about their competence, based on assumptions that they were hired simply to ‘tick a box’.”

Relationships with the FBU in both services have improved, says the report although it adds they remain “strained” in NWFRS. Responding to the publication of both reports, the FBU said they showed “systemic failures in senior management” and that firefighters deserved better. Gareth Tovey, FBU executive council member for Wales said: “Urgent action must be taken to tackle misogyny in both services.” He called for urgent change at the top of the fire services in Wales.

In a written statement from the Welsh Government, Jayne Bryant MS, Cabinet Secretary for Housing and local Government said she had met with the Chairs of the Fire Authorities and the Chief Fire Officers to discuss how they plan to address the reports’ findings. She said she expected there to be clear and decisive action “to dismantle these damaging cultures and ensure staff feel safe and valued in their workplace.” She added that she will be monitoring the situation and “urgently work to establish how best to achieve and sustain cultural change across the fire and rescue service.” 

“The reports contain concerning findings relating to bullying and harassment, misogyny, discrimination, inappropriate management styles and promotion based on favouritism. These are incredibly worrying behaviours which are unacceptable in any workplace.”

Jayne Bryant MS, Cabinet Secretary for Housing and local Government.

 One of the consequences of the report into South Wales Fire and Rescue Service was the removal of the Fire and Rescue Authority and the imposition of four independent commissioners by the Welsh Government. A recommendations in each report is for the Welsh Government to urgently governance reforms in place for the fire and rescue authority, although it doesn’t go so far as to suggest replicating the approach in the south.

North Wales Fire and Rescue Service and Mid and West Wales Fire and Rescue Service both published independent cultural reviews by Crest Advisory into their services on 5 February. The reviews focus on organisational culture and attempt to understand current and former staff’s experiences of what happens in practice and on the ground.

The research for both services took place in parallel between July and November last year and used the same methodology, with a mixture of survey, interviews and focus reports involving current and past member of staff from the two services. Hundreds of staff provided input to both reports.


Read the reviews in full here:

Independent Culture Review of North Wales Fire and Rescue Service

Independent Culture Review of Mid and West Wales Fire and Rescue Service

Crest Advisory Culture Harrassment and bullying Mid and West Wales FRS North Wales FRS South Wales FRS
Share. LinkedIn Twitter Facebook Email

Catherine Levin

  • View LinkedIn profile

Catherine writes and commissions content from across the emergency services as well as interviewing senior leaders. She also hosts our webinar series exploring timely topics with a range of speakers.

All articles by Catherine >

Stay informed

Sign up for our weekly newsletter with news, views and more.

Published by
Ninteen
Quick links
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookie policy
  • About
  • Back issues
  • Contributors
  • Contact
In assocation with
The Emergency Services Show
The Emergency Tech Show
Certifications
The Emergency Tech Show
LinkedIn Instagram
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookie policy
  • About
  • Back issues
  • Contributors
  • Contact
© 2026 Emergency Services Times.

Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.

Login